Abstract
Recent studies show that hybrid panchromatic sharpening (pan-sharpening) methods using the non-sub-sampled contourlet transform (NSCT) and classical pan-sharpening methods such as intensity, hue and saturation (IHS), principal component analysis (PCA), and adaptive principal component analysis (APCA) reduce spectral distortion in pan-sharpened images. The NSCT is a shift-invariant multi-resolution decomposition. It is based on non-sub-sampled pyramid (NSP) decomposition and non-sub-sampled directional filter banks (NSDFBs). We compare the performance of the APCA-NSCT using different NSP filters, NSDFB filters, number of decomposition levels, and number of orientations in each level on SPOT 4 data with a spatial resolution ratio of 1:2, and Quickbird data with a spatial resolution ratio of 1:4. Experimental results show that the quality of pan-sharpening of remote-sensing images of different spatial resolution ratios using the APCA-NSCT method is affected by NSCT parameters. For the NSP, the maxflat' filters have the best quality, while the sk' filters give the best quality for the NSDFB. Changing the number of orientations at the same level of decomposition in the NSCT has a small effect on both the spectral and spatial qualities. The spectral and spatial qualities of pan-sharpened images mainly depend on the number of decomposition levels. Too few decomposition levels result in poor spatial quality, while excessive levels of decomposition result in poor spectral quality. Two levels of decomposition in the case of SPOT 4 data with a spatial resolution ratio of 1:2 achieve the best results. Also, three levels of decomposition in the case of QuickBird data with a spatial resolution ratio of 1:4 show the best results.