Abstract
Objective
To explore the preference among the Saudi population regarding breaking bad news (BBN) for the participant cases and their relatives and to determine the associated sociodemographic factors.
Method
A cross-sectional study was conducted among patients and companions attending inpatient and outpatient clinics of a tertiary care hospital in Western Saudi Arabia from 15 Jan to 30 May 2015. A six-item scale was designed to assess preference regarding diagnosis disclosure in three hypothetical conditions including chronic disease, incurable disease, and cancer if the participant or a close relative is concerned, separately. A BBN preference score (BBN-PS) was computed (range=0-6), with a higher score indicating a greater preference to disclose the diagnosis. Eventual motivations for diagnosis disclosure or withholding were explored.
Result
Five hundred participants were included; 56.0% were females and 55.0% were aged between 18 and 25 years. Preference to be informed with one's diagnosis varied between 81.8% for incurable disease and 94.2% for chronic disease with complications. Preference to inform a relative with their diagnosis ranged between 69.0% for incurable disease and 86.8% for chronic disease with complications. Preference for diagnosis withholding was lower among participants of the younger age category (38.2% vs 51.2% or higher, p=0.002), with higher education (42.4% vs 60.8%, p=0.001), and working or studying in the medical field (39.7% vs 51.9%, p=0.006), compared to their counterparts, respectively. The most common motivations toward diagnosis disclosure preference were to enable the concerned person participate in their therapeutic decision (36.4%) and cope with the disease (27.4%); while preference toward diagnosis withholding was most commonly motivated by apprehensions regarding the psychological and social impact of the diagnosis (61.6%).
Conclusion
A non-negligible proportion of individuals prefer concealing a diagnosis of cancer or incurable disease to a relative, with an inter-generational disparity showing a shift to diagnosis disclosure in the young generations. There is an unmet need for evidence-based protocols for BBN based on a comprehensive assessment of patients' expectations and needs, considering their cultural and religious values as well as the specific sociodemographic and clinical factors.