Abstract
Carbapenem inactivation method (CIM) and modified carbapenem inactivation method (mCIM) were recently developed for rapid detection of carbapenemase producing Gram negative bacilli (CP-GNB). In this study we compared the ability of modified Hodge test (MHT), CIM and mCIM to identify CP-GNB in Oman and India.
Fifty fully characterized and genotyped CP-GNB (26 OXA-48-like, 2 NDM-1 from Oman and 22 NDM-1 from India) and 8 AmpC as controls in India were subjected to MHT, CIM, mCIM and mCIM with in-house modifications. Wilcoxon paired test and receiver operating characteristics (ROC) were utilised for statistical analysis.
Isolates were predominantly OXA-48-like genes producing Klebsiella pneumoniae from Oman and NDM-1 producing Escherichia coli from India. MHT was positive in all except one OXA-48-like producers and in 70.8 % of the NDM-1 isolates. The sensitivity of CIM in detecting 0XA-48 like and NDM-1 carbapenemases were 39.2% and 87.5% respectively. mCIM at 4 h detected 92.3 % and 79.1% of 0XA-48 and NDM-1 respectively. Using receiver operative characteristics (ROC), highest sensitivity and specificity for detection of OXA-48-like was obtained by mCIM at 4 h at cut off 17 mm while for NDM-1 CIM was the test of choice at 16 mm.
CIM and mCIM are simple, cheap and easy tests to perform. CIM gave excellent results with NDM1 strains while it was quite poor in predicting OXA-48-like. We recommend CIM and eCIM for rapid identification of NDM-1 producers and mCIM at 4 h and MHT for detection of OXA-48-like. No one method can correctly detect both genotypes. As determined by ROC curves a zone of inhibition of 17 mm was considered adequate for detection of OXA-48-like and 16 mm of NDM-1 by mCIM at 4 h and CIM respectively.